Academia – tradition and renewal


– tradition and renewal in an American lodge

Last summer I spent three months in California. I had several positive Masonic experiences, but the best by far was Academia Lodge in Oakland. This piece, describing my visits, was just published in a Norwegian Masonic magazine.

I arrived with my prejudices in the suitcase: expectations of a more “down to earth” Freemasonry, centred on barbecue rather than spiritual work, less formal, less dignified. And yes, the approach is markedly different; it does reflect American open-mindedness; in the same way that you might say that reticence and conservatism is typical of our own Freemasonry, because that is who we are as Scandinavians. Like I said: prejudice. I guess the important lesson here is not to tar everyone with the same brush. Which brings me to Academia.

Traditional Observance
Academia is a new lodge, a mere four years old, which has been permitted to work according to the principles of “Traditional Observance” (TO). On the website of Masonic Restoration Foundation (MRF) we read that »Traditional Observance Freemasonry is not a Masonic Rite, but rather a best-practices model. In many ways, TO Masonry is a response to some of the negative trends experienced by North American Freemasonry in recent years, aimed at reversing those trends and restoring the strength and dignity of the American Craft.« MRF offers some standards that must be met, before you have a TO lodge. But it is important to understand that the TO lodges are still working within the existing tenets of their grand lodge.

It is a curious thing trying to describe Academia as something unique, because coming from Denmark this was in many ways what I have been used to from home – but it was also strikingly clear that this was something “new” in the States. These are just a few key points: The brethren are dressed in tails or tuxedo, and as guests it was explained to us how we were to enter the lodge in procession, and that we were to remain silent during the ritual. The lodge room is lit by candles, and Academia has introduced a Chain of Union as well as a Chamber of Reflection, as it is known in many continental, particularly French lodges. In addition lectures are given, and there is a full sit-down meal after the work. All this is familiar to us, but not a given standard “Over There”. Academia typically have 10-20 Brethren present (attendance is compulsory), but often has just as many guests wanting to look in on what they are doing there. I couldn’t help but appreciating the privilege of being a member of an Order that takes these things for granted: tradition, Masonic education, lectures, beautiful rituals and solemn fraternal conversation.

n628286812_455191_32921First encounter
As soon as I arrived at Oakland’s beautiful Scottish Rite Temple (build in the 1920’s, and, very Californian, with sun panels on the roof), I had my first surprise. I was greeted by the founder of the lodge, Br. DC, and he wore a lodge jewel from St. John’s Lodge Kosmos in Elsinore (just north of Copenhagen)! The “Academians” are still waiting for their own jewels, but for now Kosmos was the one that came closest; but other than that there was no relation.

I also met Br. DM, an “old hippie” – in the best sense of the word – with whom I had been in contact over the Internet, and with typical Californian hospitality he vouched for me before the Brethren, once he had checked my passport and credentials. My host for the evening though was Br. AK, and when he finally escaped the San Francisco traffic he gave countermand, insisting on examination. At this point I had already been escorted into the lodge room, so there was a brief moment of apprehension, when the Marshal came to bring me back out. Br. AK and some of the other Master Masons clearly found the experience quite interesting, for there was hardly a single gesture or word on which we could fully agree. But by the end of it, everyone was satisfied. There was an Initiation on the program, and the ritual work was first rate; all lines were memorised and given with great solemnity. There was also a lecture – education is something Academia sees as a priority – as well as fine dining, with wine and toasts.

Before we said our goodbyes, we had a quiet moment on the balcony overlooking Lake Merritt in the centre of Oakland – it was like being transported back in time, for the temple has retained its wonderful view over a city that has seen some rough times, but is slowly finding its feet again.

n628286812_455192_3531The Grand Master on the sideline
A few weeks later I was back. It was a special evening as the Grand Master of California at that time, Melvyn B. Stein, was there as a guest. He had invited himself over to see what all the fuss was about. At the same time Academia had invited the Past Grand Orator of Arizona, John T. Shattuck, who himself had helped start a TO lodge. And he gave a lecture that gave off sparks! He had some hard words for the direction American Freemasonry had taken – in his opinion it could barely be called Freemasonry any more – and the words carried an additional edge with a leading representative of the existing system as a listener. But when taken together with the exemplary work of the lodge, these were not just empty words, and the following discussion over dinner was uplifting: Every guest, including the Grand Master’s retinue, expressed that this was Freemasonry the way they had dreamed it would be; or, in the words of one guest, this was his best experience in 46 years as a freemason. So the will to go back to the roots is definitely there (and apropos of roots: Freemasonry in California traces its roots back to Denmark via the pioneer Peter Lassen, but that’s a different story).

new_seal_draft_200_300I spoke on a few occasions with Br. AK while I was in the city, and he told me that Academia was in essence a symbol: If they couldn’t carry their responsibility and prove its worth, it would be a huge setback for Traditional Observance in all of California, so there was a lot at stake. But his commitment – and that of his fellow Brethren and founders of Academia – offers hope that they will still be around, when I return one day.

By Thomas Munkholt, III°
St. John’s Lodge Hafnia, Copenhagen, The Danish Order of Freemasons
Published in LogeKjeden no. 3/08
Photos: August 17, 2007

6 thoughts on “Academia – tradition and renewal

  1. Dear Brother Thomas
    Thank you for this blog
    I really enjoyed having the insight at this freemasonry that we often hear of without really knowing it : the freemasonry of Denmark and on a wider range, the freemasonry of the Swedish rite
    Keep up the good work
    Fraternal greetings to you and your lodge
    Georgious, i.O. eques a Valle sancta – Grand Priory of Gaulles (France)

  2. Thank you Bro. Thomas for your story and your encouragement! I hope my countermand for examination was not as harsh as it may appear; it was for the fact that the brethren had overlooked this important aspect. It is a universal custom to test a brother visiting if he has not visited the lodge previously. Yes, I was your host this evening and we had known each other previously online, but we still enjoy the customary and codified testing in order to view another’s work–not only as a prerequisite for entry, but also to share a private moment of Masonic communication. In addition, this custom establishes, quite formally, the fact that all present can now vouch for each other when visiting our respective lodges.

    I am always pleased to be asked to show my work when visiting another lodge to which I am unfamiliar. It is a singular experience and one that is treasured as a part of my memories (so if I visit Denmark, please test me even though we can now vouch for each other).

    I am so happy that we were finally able to meet and that friendships can, with greater ease with the aid of technology, truly reach across the geographic boundaries.

  3. IF you visit …?

    And yes, I did emphasise that part of the story for, shall we say drama, and it may have some across harsher than it was. The surprise for me was actually NOT being proved.

    It was also a good thing to settle in advance that I would give different signs etc. due to our system, so that I didn’t appear a complete amateur in lodge.

  4. I’ll try to be brief – sittting in my summer cottage in Southern France for the summer (in the fall of my life) this blog came to me from brother DL in Virginia in whose Lodge I have been welcomed since my renewed exodus two years ago from Switzerland – and my home Lodge Libertas et Concordia in Chur. It has been a very diappointing time for me to sit in a temple where nothing but business and mutual aggrandizement with picture taking make up the substance of the monthly called communications. – Except for brother DL and three other brothers (yes, four brothers in a Lodge of some 160 members I would guess) who invited me to their monthly discussion group which, the only opportunity to ever even speak of the Masonic philosophy and practice. So you can understand that this blog makes my heart beat faster and rekindles hopes that maybe, maybe there is even hope for us! Thank you! Hansueli Steiner

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s